[Back to Interviews & Articles

Bonnie Foreshaw Case on WTIC 1080
Monday January 9, 2006


Mornings with Ray Dunaway and Diane Smith

WTIC 1080 AM
Monday - Friday
5:30 - 10am

Connecticut's number one way to wake up!
Join Ray Dunaway, Diane Smith and the rest of the WTIC Morning Team for all the information and topical talk you need to get you going in the morning.

News - with Angela Dias
Weather - with Joe Furey
Traffic Reports - with Mike Allan and Gerri Griswold
Sports - with Scott Gray

Plus, conversation about the day's hot topics with Ray and Diane!

Upcoming Guests

You won't want to miss this! Look what's coming up on the morning show with Ray and Diane!

Monday 1/9

Alan Russell
Chairman of the Schaghticoke Indian Tribal Council
Re: Separation From Tribe

Joe Amarante
TV Critic for the New Haven Register


Re: Upcoming TV Season
[scheduled 9:05 a.m.]

Andy Thibault
Author of  "Law & Justice in Everyday Life," Columnist for Law Tribune Newspapers, Adjunct Professor of Journalism at the University of Hartford and [Case Manager, McNicholas Associates].
Re: Bonnie Foreshaw Case


Mahmood Monshipouri
Political Science Professor at Quinnipiac University
Re: President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad Banning Western Music in Iran

 

9:05 a.m. Bonnie Foreshaw case


RD – Ray Dunaway

DS – Diane Smith

AT – Andy Thibault

RD – [Humming to the bumper music.] Who’s this? Who’s this guy? By the way, WTIC. Hey, good morning, welcome to the program. Ray Dunaway. And Diane Smith is here, and by and large, we’re having the best times of our lives. Thank you for being part of it.

DS – Here it is.

RD – We’ll take calls after 9:30. We’re going to talk about a couple of things. To get you up to speed on things, Andy Thibault, who you know, has been on this show before. He is a columnist for The Law Tribune. And a very interesting guy in his own right. Anyway, he has taken on a cause, and it all really goes back a ways. First of all, Andy, great to have you on, buddy.

AT --  Hey, Ray, you got the beat. Thanks for having me on.

RD – We got the beat, baby, we got the beat. This is the story of a woman named Bonnie Foreshaw. Correct?

AT – Yes sir.

RD – First of all, let’s get the facts of the case. Because you’ve written a letter to Gov. Rell saying, look, this woman was not fairly charged, she was unfairly sentenced, this woman should be out by now. So what are the particulars of this case?

AT – Sure, Ray. I’ve been assured early in December that this would make it to Gov. Rell’s desk. Every day Bonnie Foreshaw remains in prison, I think, is a crime against humanity perpetrated by the state of Connecticut. Just a little bit about Bonnie: She gave birth to her first child at age 12. She’s been a victim of violence and sexual abuse from childhood through her time in prison. That abuse has continued. After she was beaten by her third husband she carried a gun for protection. She was a machinist for Wiremold Company in Hartford for 10 years, shop steward, bought a house in Bloomfield, cared for her children. And her third husband continued to stalk her. One night she stopped for a drink at the Jamaican Progressive League in Hartford. A man named Hector Freeman offered her a drink. She declined. Freeman pursued her, would not leave her alone, followed her to her car. He came toward her, he reached into his pocket, she feared he was going to pull a knife or a gun. And Freeman admittedly pulled a pregnant woman in front of him. Bonnie fired her gun. She hit the pregnant woman who died. And that woman was used as a human shield. A young, ambitious assistant state’s attorney James Thomas grossly overcharged Bonnie.

RD – What did he charge her with?

AT – Premeditated murder of a person she had never met. So Thomas stepped on Bonnie in a shameful and cowardly way to advance his career. He has a chance to redeem himself by supporting – or not opposing – Bonnie’s release when she goes before the Board of Pardons and Parole this year.

DS – Andy, what would have been appropriate, what kind of action might have been appropriate legally?

AT – Manslaughter. She would have been out years ago. She’s served 20 years. The so-called Correction Department – which I would call the Department of Sadism, Deception and Lies – gave Bonnie a Christmas present. They stole her medical mattress. She has rheumatoid arthritis and she’s been given an old, dirty mattress – one that should have been thrown away. And she was sexually assaulted in prison last year and that was covered up. So, I mean, we have a Gulag here in Connecticut and people need to know about it.

DS – Andy, why do you think this is happening? I mean, you’re using pretty strong terms.

AT –[Commissioner] Theresa Lantz has good intentions, but she’s not getting the job done. Between her and the prisoners there are a lot of sadists and nincompoops. In fact, regarding the guard who allegedly assaulted Bonnie, another guard came to Bonnie’s cell and called that guard a hero.

RD – Let me ask you something, Andy. There’s no excuse for this. In fact, this did happen. But, has she been by and large a model prisoner?

AT -- As Wally Lamb, who tutors her in the writing group, says, she’s been a surrogate mother and grandmother to many troubled women and teen-age girls, she’s active in Literacy Volunteers, Alternatives to Violence and the Hospice Program. She’s a model prisoner, a woman of great self control, she’s sorry for what she did and she’s redeemed herself.

DS – Andy, you said she’s already served 20 years, right?

AT – Yeah.

DS – I mean, a lot of people who go to prison on pre-meditated murder charges rightfully, don’t serve 20 years.

AT – I know a guy who walked into a courtroom in Norwich, pumped five bullets into his wife in a divorce case and said, “Now I can sleep at night.” He was only sentenced to 12 years.

DS – What could happen, what’s the possibility here, what’s the only way for Bonnie Foreshaw  [to get out] …

AT – Well, it’s tough. She has to get a hearing. But I believe there are good people who will do their duty on the Board of Pardons and Parole. She has an all-star legal team. There’s a guy named Clint Roberts, who’s an expert on sentence review; Hartford Atty. John Andreini, [Atty.] Rich Meehan, who you know and [Atty.] Mary Werblin are her legal team. So she’s got an all-star team, she’s got a just cause and we asked the governor to turn the spotlight on this.

DS – It’s not a case where the governor could act on her own, is it?

AT – No, she couldn’t. But, as I mentioned to her staff: When things were rotten in New London, Ella Grasso got involved in the cover-up of a hit-and-run.

DS – So Ella Grasso kind of brought it out and brought it to some kind of an airing?

AT – She put papers on the desk of Supreme Court Justice John Cotter, who ordered a one-man grand jury led by Joseph Dannehy and Austin McGuigan.

DS – What we’re talking about with Bonnie Foreshaw here also if she were to serve her entire sentence, isn’t she still facing like 25 more years?

AT – Yeah, she got sentenced to about 45, I forget how many years. The longest sentence of any woman in Connecticut history. She’s 57, she’s in ill health.

RD—So, she’ll die in prison.

AT – She’s being mistreated every day. I told you what she got for Christmas.

DS – I’ll ask you another question, OK, this is, we talk about a prison system where we believe in rehabilitation. And we call it the Department of Correction, not the Department of Punishment because we believe people can turn their lives around with some assistance. This sounds like a person who if in fact was guilty of the crime in the first place in the way that they portrayed it – which sounds like it was a miscarriage at that point – the woman has certainly … achieved rehabilitation according to your account.

AT – The greatest crime you can commit as a prisoner is to pretend you are a human being. Because you’ll be punished for that.

DS—And you say she’s done that by acting as a surrogate mother and grandmother to some of the other inmates?

AT – Yeah, what they want you to do is stay in your cell. To get to any program you have to run through a gauntlet. It’s much easier to just stay in your cell and just rot away.

DS – You say you got to know her through Wally Lamb’s writing workshop. Wally, of course, as most people know, is a world-famous novelist and he did put together a wonderful book a few years ago written by women in that writing workshop. I’m trying to remember now, was Bonnie one of them?

AT – Yes, she was. She had a great piece in there. And, of course, you remember that they punished the prisoners for trying to redeem themselves and writing about it.

DS – Although, wasn’t that eventually turned around, Andy.

AT – Yeah, Blumenthal saw the light when 60 Minutes flashed a light in his face.

DS – Uh huh.

RD – Well, Andy, I’ll tell you what. Once again, the name of the woman is … Bonnie Foreshaw.

AT – Bonnie Foreshaw must go free.

RD – And she’s been in for quite a while.

AT – Twenty years.

RD – [Facing] another 25 years, she was sentenced to 45 years. There was no hope of parole whatsoever?

AT – Her legal team is trying to get her a hearing with the Board of Pardons and Parole. We’re optimistic that will happen.

DS – If people in the audience wanted to take up her cause, is there something that people can do that is simple that doesn’t involve having to go and protest or call 60 Minutes of whatever? Is there something they can try to do to get this to happen?

AT – They could inquire to their legislators, write to the governor, write to the Board of Pardons and Paroles, you can get all that with a google.

RD—And it is Bonnie Foreshaw. Once, again, I want to thank you, Andy, for being on. Let’s stay in touch and let us know how it goes.

AT – Thanks so much Ray and Diane.

DS—Thanks, Andy.

RD – Andy Thibault. This also ran, the piece he sent us, ran in The Norwich Bulletin and The Law Tribune.

DS – And The New London Day. It was originally one of the columns that Andy writes for The Connecticut Law Tribune, but those two papers, New London Day and Norwich Bulletin, picked it up. And I might say that Brian Garnett, the former reporter for Channel 3 who’s now a spokesperson for the Department of Correction, had a few unkind comments about it. I think if all he’s asking for here is a hearing. You know, he’s not asking for clemency. Obviously, that’s what Andy thinks should happen. But, he’s asking for a hearing among people that he considers to be just and fair.

RD – Well, let’s get on the record whether she has been a good prisoner, whether there have been issues. I mean, you know, just get it out there. I agree.

DS – What’s so scary about a hearing?

RD – It’s 9:18 on WTIC

Back to Top